Live demo
BeginnerTry it: AI chart check lab
This is the working lab from our tutorial on checking an AI-made chart before it goes in the board packet. Each row is one chart in an invented November board packet, from members by career stage to exhibitor booth sales. Choose the nine facts for each chart and the page sorts every chart into STOP, VERIFY or PASS as you go.
Invented Tarnbeck Society of Lighthouse Lens Restorers. Invented examples for practice. Not a full chart review. This is a teaching example, not a case study. The page runs fixed, deterministic rules on the choices made here; it reads no chart, calls no AI tool, and sends and stores nothing.
Pick a case
Every dropdown starts empty. Fill the rows yourself, or load a practice case.
What each field means
| Field | Choices |
|---|---|
| Chart type | Bar, Line, Pie or Stacked bar |
| Value axis | Starts at zero; Starts above zero, break marked; Starts above zero, no break marked; or No value axis (pie charts) |
| Plotted numbers | All checked against the source table, Some checked, or Not checked |
| Value axes | One value axis or Two value axes |
| Categories, lines or segments | Up to 4, 5, or 6 or more |
| Parts | Parts add to a whole, or Parts do not add to a whole |
| Negative values | No negative values or Has negative values |
| Source line | Specific source, linked; Organization name only; or No source |
| Title | Says what, where and when; Headline only; or No title |
Charts
| Chart | What it shows | Chart type | Value axis | Plotted numbers | Value axes | Categories, lines or segments | Parts | Negative values | Source line | Title |
|---|
Rules, in order (first match wins)
- R1, STOP: nobody checked the plotted numbers against the source table. This is our rule, not the guidance's.
- R2, STOP: a bar or stacked bar chart whose value axis starts above zero, with or without a marked break.
- R3, STOP: the chart has two value axes.
- R4, STOP: a pie chart whose parts do not add to a whole.
- R5, VERIFY: a field is empty, holds a value outside its list, or does not fit the chart type.
- R6, VERIFY: a line chart that starts above zero with no break marked.
- R7, VERIFY: only some plotted numbers were checked against the source table. This is our rule, not the guidance's.
- R8, VERIFY: a pie chart with six or more slices.
- R9, VERIFY: a line or stacked bar chart with five or more lines or segments.
- R10, VERIFY: a stacked bar chart with negative values.
- R11, VERIFY: the source line names only an organization, or there is no source.
- R12, VERIFY: the title is a headline only, or there is no title.
- PASS: none of the rules above matched.
Teaching choices: we picked these rules, their order and the three verdicts for teaching. R2 to R4 and R6 to R12 draw on UK government statistics guidance, which does not rank anything. R1 and R7 are our own rules; the guidance says nothing about checking an AI tool's chart. A PASS never means the chart is right.
Result
No charts sorted yet.
Rule hits: none yet.
| Chart | What it shows | Verdict | First rule | Also matches | Message |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nothing sorted yet. | |||||
Not sorted yet.
Plain-text record
Nothing sorted yet.
This is a teaching tool. A PASS means only that nothing entered on this page raised a flag for one chart. These fields cover part of the guidance, and a chart can pass them and still say the wrong thing. It is not a full chart review and it does not check any real chart.