Live demo
BeginnerTry it: member comment campaign check lab
This is the working lab from our tutorial on checking a member comment campaign before it is submitted. Each row is one invented comment queued for the Invented Velmorrow Association of Home Health Agencies. You record whether the named member approved it, who wrote it, how much first-hand detail it has, how closely it matches another comment, leftover placeholders, and whether the facts were checked, then see whether the comment should stop, be fixed, or pass.
Invented organization, rule and comments for practice. This is a teaching example, not a case study. The lab checks only the entries you type on this page. It does not call any AI tool and sends nothing anywhere.
Pick a case
Code key
| Field | How to fill it |
|---|---|
| Approved | Y or N, uppercase only: did the named member approve sending this under their name? |
| Written by | M the member wrote it; A a tool drafted it and the member edited it; G a tool generated it and the member did not write or change it |
| Own sentences | Whole number from 0 to 20: sentences that describe the member's own situation |
| Match % | Share of the text that matches another comment in the batch, from 0 to 100 (decimals allowed) |
| Leftover | Whole number from 0 to 20: leftover placeholders or unused brackets |
| Facts | Y or N, uppercase only: facts checked against the rule text |
ACUS Recommendation 2021-1 defines mass comments as comments submitted in large volumes, including identical or substantively identical ones; computer-generated comments as those whose "substantive content has been generated by computer software rather than by humans"; and falsely attributed comments as "comments attributed to people who did not submit them." Thresholds and STOP or FIX choices are teaching choices.
Comments in this case
| Row | Approved | Written by | Own sentences | Match % | Leftover | Facts |
|---|
Rules, in order (first match wins)
- R1, FIX: a field is blank, the wrong type, out of range, or not one of the listed uppercase codes. A blank is never read as 0.
- R2, STOP: Approved is N. The named member has not approved sending this under their name.
- R3, STOP: Written by is G. The text was generated and the member did not write or change it.
- R4, FIX: leftover placeholders are 1 or more. Checking for leftover template text is a teaching choice.
- R5, FIX: Match % is 80 or higher. Consider folding the text into one sign-on comment with multiple signatures.
- R6, FIX: own-situation sentences are 0.
- R7, FIX: Facts is N.
- R8, PASS: everything else. A PASS means the comment is ready for the member's final look; it is not a prediction of agency weight.
Teaching choices: the 80 percent match line, the zero-sentence line, leftover placeholders, which pairs count as STOP or FIX, and the rule order. Categories follow the recommendation's definitions. Applying them to an association's own batch, including treating an unedited AI draft as computer-generated, is our reading.
Result
| Row | Approved | Written by | Own sentences | Match % | Leftover | Facts | Verdict | Rule ID | Also matched | Message |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pick a case. | ||||||||||
Not checked yet.
Plain-text record (select and copy it by hand)
Nothing checked yet.
This is a teaching tool. A PASS means one comment matched the checks on this page. It does not predict how an agency will weigh the comment, and it is not a replacement for reading the rule or talking with the member.