AssociationAI / AI Literacy
AssociationAI team Published

Article

Beginner

Before Another Call for Volunteers: What Five Sources Say About the Role and the First Months, and What None of Them Tested

Five sources describe what stood between people and a volunteer seat and what went with staying. None tested changing the role, so the changes here are our reading.

Volunteers Committee Chapters Membership Research

When a committee or chapter seat has stayed empty for a term, the usual request to staff is one more call for volunteers. In a June 2017 committee report to the council of the Society of American Archivists, a survey of the society’s own members that is not research and not peer reviewed, roughly half of the 1,279 people who answered (about 665) said they wanted to be more involved in the society. Wanting to help and filling a seat are different things, and the same report ranks the barriers people named. We read it beside four other sources to see what they say about the volunteer role and what a new volunteer meets in the first months, before another call goes out.

Five sources, five different groups of people

A 2018 article in the International Journal of Volunteer Administration, by an author at Old Dominion University, reanalyzed a 2007 to 2008 survey in which 26,305 members of professional associations returned questionnaires, a 14 percent response rate. A 2022 paper from Volunteering Australia, whose research series states its papers are peer reviewed and whose author is an adjunct research associate at Flinders University, drew on focus groups and on a survey that a little over 1,500 people answered, three quarters of them from small South Australian clubs run by volunteers without paid staff. A 2023 article in the Journal of Public and Nonprofit Affairs, by two authors at the University of North Carolina at Charlotte, analyzed 323 usable answers to a voluntary survey of volunteers at US nonprofits, collected from January to April 2020. A March 2007 research brief from the federal Corporation for National and Community Service analyzed household-survey panels from 2002 to 2006 of Baby Boomers who volunteered. No source we read studied a chapter, a role redesign, or a program run by an association with paid staff, so every change suggested below is our reading and untested.

What people said stood between them and a seat

The committee report ranks the barriers named by the people who answered: expense and time first and second, new professionals not feeling experienced enough third, unclear ways to take part fourth, and not being appointed after volunteering fifth. The survey defined taking part broadly, including attending the annual meeting, and the copy we read prints no counts for the barriers. The report adds that some people were discouraged by never hearing back after offering to volunteer or proposing a session, and that some past leaders who found the experience unfulfilling had not sought new roles.

In the Australian survey, 67 percent of respondents from small volunteer-run clubs reported difficulty recruiting leaders, against 49 percent of respondents from associations with paid staff, answers from South Australia in 2022 that split respondents by group, test no program and do not describe professional associations. Focus group participants called the misuse of power and internal politics the primary barrier to joining committees, followed by lack of time, red tape and low self-confidence, while the survey respondents named fear of responsibility as a leading factor, followed closely by lack of time. Among respondents from small clubs, 78 percent agreed that mostly the same individuals serve on the committee year after year. The author reports that over-formal meeting procedures seemed to deepen younger members’ feeling that they lacked the skills to lead, a reading the author draws from nine focus group participants aged 45 or under.

What went with staying once someone said yes

The 2018 article measured intention, not behavior: members rated how likely they were to volunteer for their association in the next 12 months. Of the three kinds of satisfaction it modeled, only the societal kind, which reflects satisfaction with giving back, socializing and working together toward common goals, had a strong positive effect on that intention. Its author concludes that meeting volunteers’ motives and keeping them satisfied is not by itself a direct route to lasting volunteering.

The Charlotte article asked volunteers how likely they were to volunteer again in the next year. In its model, inclusion and training were statistically significant positive predictors of that intention for this sample, while satisfaction with logistics, such as project options and ease of registering, showed no significant link. Inclusion was a four-question scale on acceptance and belonging, and training was one yes or no question about having appropriate training and support, and 94 percent answered yes, so the training result rests on few people who said no and is not a rule. The authors warn that a voluntary survey may not be representative, and respondents who described little training said they felt ignored, not valued, apprehensive and “just thrown in”.

In the federal brief’s household-survey panels from 2002 to 2006, 31 percent of Baby Boomers who volunteered in the first year did not volunteer in the second, a count of people who stopped volunteering through or with any organization, not of people who left one association. For programs whose activities appeal less to Baby Boomers, the brief says it may be imperative to consider making them more attractive or reconsidering how volunteers are used, which is advice, not a test.

Three changes to try before the next call

In our reading, the sources share one thread: much of what they report concerns the role and the first months, not the wording of the call. These three follow from that thread, and none of them appears in the sources as a tested change.

  1. Write the role as a short description with an estimated number of hours for a term, a named person to report to, and a first task. The committee report suggests descriptions of leadership positions with estimated time requirements as an idea of its own, and in the Charlotte survey 10 of the 157 respondents who wrote comments on supporting volunteers asked for better supervision, with clear tasks and clarity about whom to report to.
  2. Plan the first months before anyone arrives: who greets the volunteer, what the first meeting asks of them, and who explains how the group works. This reads the Charlotte result on inclusion and training as a reason to try it.
  3. Reply to everyone who offered, including people not placed, with a date for the answer and another way to take part. The report’s fifth barrier and its comments on never hearing back point here.

Keep your own record of offers, placements and who is still serving a year later, so the next decision rests on your own counts.

Sources (5)