AssociationAI / AI Literacy
AssociationAI team Published

Article

Beginner

Before Rewriting the First Renewal Notice: What Five Sources Say About a New Member's First 90 Days, and Where the Evidence Stops

Five sources describe contact, orientation and mentoring in a member's first months. The changes drawn from them here are our reading and have not been tested.

Membership Retention Onboarding New Members Research

A cohort of new members joined this autumn, their first renewal is months away, and someone on the team has asked for a better renewal notice. None of the five sources describes testing the wording of a renewal notice; what they describe happens earlier, in contact, orientation and mentoring. Before that work starts, staff can ask an earlier question: what do those members meet in their first 90 days, and what does the research say about it? We read five sources on the first months of membership, and none of them studied an association’s first-90-day program against what share of new members renewed at their first renewal.

What a society counted in its first years

A 2014 editorial in the Canadian Journal of Hospital Pharmacy, by the President Elect of the Canadian Society of Hospital Pharmacists, reports the society’s analysis of its own membership from 2008/2009 to 2012/2013. In that editorial, retention was 60 percent among first-year pharmacist members. The same 2014 editorial puts retention at 35 percent among pharmacy residents and postgraduate students moving from training to Active membership. A third figure from that 2014 editorial, 69 percent, is for members who renew beyond their second year of active membership, a group the editorial does not define further. Each number describes a different group, so none of them is set against another here.

The society says the first two years are the most critical in deciding whether a member finds value, and its author calls for energy and focus on the first-year pharmacists and the residents and postgraduates. That is a view, not a tested step, and the editorial names no program.

A 2019 Associations Now feature, by one of its senior editors, relays one association’s account of a live onboarding webinar that reviews member benefits and shows where to find online tools. The page says the association has seen a correlation between webinar participation and higher retention, and it reports that first-year retention rose by 6 percent in 2018, a figure it does not define, compare or source. That is one association’s own claim with no method behind it, and it does not show that the webinar did anything.

What new members met in the first month

A 2017 guide from the Jobs With Justice Education Fund about union members makes the case for new hire orientations. It includes research by a Penn State professor on 494 new members, in six states, who had joined one large national union the year before and were surveyed in spring 2016 and spring 2017. In that survey, 46.2 percent of the new members who completed it said they had no contact with the union during their first month. Among the same new members, 37.7 percent had experienced a new hire orientation. Those two figures measure contact and attendance, not renewal.

The guide also reports commitment to the union, as the report measured it. New members who attended an orientation and found it helpful had a significantly higher level of commitment than those who did not, while members who found an orientation unhelpful had a significantly lower level than both the helpful group and those who did not attend. “Significantly” is the report’s word. It adds that longer orientations were rated as more helpful, and that commitment differed little between the early months and about a year later, including for members whose orientation was helpful, unhelpful or absent. We read these as attitudes at the time of the survey, with no cause shown, and none of them measures renewal.

A youth program and a small chapter pilot

A 2022 article in the Journal of Human Sciences and Extension (copy on the federal education library site), by authors at university Cooperative Extension units and an agricultural experiment station, covers a 4-H youth program in nine US states, not an association. It surveyed first-year members near the end of their first year, across program years 2016-17 to 2018-19. Of the 1,927 to 1,953 youth who answered the items on why they might leave, 19.9 percent said it was completely or a little true that they did not feel connected to other youth in their club, and 8.9 percent said the same of not feeling welcomed. The authors also report a theme of youth not knowing expectations, how to do things, or when meetings would take place, and say first-year members suggested orientations and mentors. Asked whether they planned to re-enroll, 79 percent said yes, which is stated intent and not renewal.

A 2024 article by two Weber State University authors describes a small pilot in one chapter of a professional nursing organization. Its membership committee chose 11 new members for mentoring, five active members volunteered to mentor for 3 to 6 months, and five new members answered the survey, a 45 percent response, with no comparison group. Three of the five who answered said they were very likely to renew the next year, which the source reports as 60 percent. That is a stated likelihood, and the authors say that measuring a 12-month mentoring relationship against renewal would add knowledge that this project did not.

What to change first, in our reading

No association has tried these steps; they are drawn from the five sources as we read them. Count before changing anything: for the current cohort, record whether anyone from the association has been in touch in each member’s first month and whether each attended any orientation, the two things the union guide counted. Put the unwritten parts into the first contact, meaning how things are done, when meetings happen and whom to ask, since the youth article found a theme of members not knowing them. Ask first-year members two short questions about feeling connected and welcome at around month three, and keep the answers apart from the renewal count. If a mentor or a check-in is tried, give it to some of the cohort and keep the usual welcome for the rest, then compare renewals at the actual renewal date, because neither the youth article nor the pilot did that.

This is a teaching example, not a case study. A membership manager asked to rewrite the autumn cohort’s renewal notice first lists every new member, marks who has heard from a person at the association and who joined the orientation call, and sends the unmarked names to the committee chair with one question: who will reach these members this week? If the notice is rewritten as well, the renewal reminder tutorial covers building dated reminders from fixed rules.

The 90 days here is our working window, not a finding. The editorial points to two years, the youth survey asked after one, the union survey ran two to twelve months after joining, and the pilot mentored for three to six months.

Sources (5)